Deciding Whether Crate Training Is Best For Your Dog

I have always found crate training to be a bit cruel, but I thought that I was alone in this opinion. Most people I encounter who have dogs speak very highly of the crating process. They believe it to be essential in the training of any dog. I have had it recommended to me by many sources. I had begun to think that maybe I was mistaken about my original opinion. Then, recently, I read an article by PETA contradicting the most common beliefs about crate training. It was refreshing to know that I am not alone and that there are other views out there. So, I would like to discuss with you now a little of each side and let you come to your own conclusions about whether to crate your dog or not.

Those In Favor:

Advocates of crate training will say that dogs by nature have dens and that crates are similar to this. They feel safe in these close quarters. The crate will be viewed as the dog's own personal room that he can safely and comfortably travel to different destinations in. It is also believed that potty training is made easier because dogs typically do not relieve themselves where they sleep. Crate-lovers will list benefits such as no more damage to the house and therefore no more unnecessary punishment to the doggie. Those in favor of crate training will even find ways to make the crate a decorative part of the home. There are all kinds of crates on the market from designer crates to crates that resemble pieces of household furniture. The crate provides a convenient way to keep your dog close to you while keeping him free from harm and out of trouble.

Those Opposed:


The other view of crate training is quite the opposite. While anti-craters do recognize a dog's denning instinct they also realize that, in nature, a dog's den would never consist of a locked door. Dogs may enjoy small spaces, but they do not appreciate their total lack of freedom. However, the behavior they display that might cause some to believe they "love" their crates is really just a dog's way of being obedient. Dogs love their humans more than anything and will wait all day in a cage until they are set free to stretch, run, and enjoy time with the family. Those opposed to crate training also do not believe that the crate promotes security. However, it can lead to severe separation anxiety and depression. Dogs left home alone all day locked in a cage will often cry, bark, and howl, demonstrating  this anxiety. Being cramped up for long periods of time also can cause the dog to have too much unspent energy thereby creating a Tasmanian devil-like whirlwind of activity when the dog is actually released. This type of dog may even display more destructive behavior than a dog who has been adequately exercised and entertained throughout the day. As for crating assisting in the potty training department that is not necessarily true especially for puppies. Puppies' bladders do not even fully develop until they are around 6 months old. To expect a young dog to hold its urine for long periods of time is unrealistic and to force him to pee in his own personal space is just unkind.

How To Decide:


Of course, the decision is always up to you. There are ways of utilizing a crate in your dog's life that are less extreme than keeping him locked in it all day. However, just be open to the idea that crate training may not be as flawless and commendable as most people would have you believe. There are always other options and ways to raise a well-behaved, happy dog. We responsible dog owners must not justify our own laziness or desire for convenience  and leave our pets to suffer for the choices we make. To me, crate training a dog is very similar to parents leashing their children. And I have seen quite a number of kids on bracelet leashes and even chest harnesses. If you choose to bring a dog into your life and world prepare yourself first. Be ready to make sacrifices and tap into your surplus patience. Please share with us your opinions on crate training in the comment section below.